Understanding the Roles of Coach, Mentor, and Supervisor

Anna Warren
New Year Image


In the world of school leadership, there’s a dance we do. It’s the dance along the continuum of supervising, mentoring and coaching. This is a good thing. With our ability to shift our dance moves from one of these to another, we serve our teachers, right where they are. Sometimes, we blend these roles, or move in and out of them in one short conversation. But, the purpose, message, and sound of each are different. Let’s take a closer look:

What is Coaching?
Coaching is a supportive relationship in which the coach serves as a thinking partner to the coachee. Through powerful questioning, and a focus on the client’s skills & knowledge, the coach guides the coachee to solution oriented and action driven outcomes.

When to Use:
  • To debrief or plan a lesson or situation
  • To process a dilemma
  • To set goals
Key Elements:
  • Strengths based
  • Open-ended questioning generates thinking
  • Allows for assessment of current reality
  • Options are generated by the coachee and sometimes, the coach
  • Future and action oriented
Sounds like:
  • What went well?
  • What do you want?
  • What is next?

What is Mentoring?
Mentoring is a supportive and advising relationship, often between two people who are in the same career field. The experienced mentor trains, teaches, and advises the less experienced mentee.

When to Use:
  • To learn and tweak skills
  • To observe methods & actions
  • To get advice
  • To gain knowledge
  • To assist in goal setting
  • To hear feedback
Key Elements:
  • Mentor is experienced & knowledgeable in the field
  • Advice is sought by mentee
  • Answers, guidance, wisdom, and support are given by mentor
Sounds like:
  • Let me share with you the process I used to develop my record keeping system
  • In that situation, I would __________
  • Here is a tool I used to organize my student data

What is Supervising?
Supervising is a relationship between a boss and his/her employee. The boss may direct the actions of the employee based on their skills and areas of improvement and the alignment of those skills/improvement areas with the organization’s vision, mission, and goals.

When to Use:
  • To ensure organizational goals are met
  • To ensure growth in individual performance
  • To evaluate performance
  • To set goals
  • To ensure accountability
Key Elements:
  • Most often is a supervisor to subordinate relationship
  • Supervisor is concerned about the organization’s goals and the individual’s performance as it relates to those goals
  • Supervisor gives instructions and directions
  • Employee acts upon directives, which drives results of their evaluation
  • To ensure accountability
Sounds Like:
  • Here is my feedback on your observation
  • Make sure you are making four parent contacts per week, per our communication plan
  • I expect to see your lessons plans in our shared folder by Friday afternoon each week
It certainly takes some skill and practice to perfect these “dance moves”! But being aware of them and their differences is a good first step. And, ultimately, your teachers benefit.

(Adapted from resources provided by Region 13 Education Service Center, Coaching and Leadership Development Center, Leadership Coach Training, 2007-2011)

Saturday, June 20, 2015